I’ll admit it upfront: I’ve never been a Tube Screamer person. Every time I tried one it sounded like someone pressed a pillow against the amp, all muffled mids with the top end choked off. The EarthQuaker Devices Plumes Small Signal Shredder changed that, not by being a better TS clone, but by being something genuinely different under the hood.
EQD swapped the classic 4558 op-amp and BJT buffers for JFET operational amplifiers, and internally converts the 9V supply to a bipolar plus/minus 9V rail. More headroom is a big part of why this thing never sounds congested. It’s chewy and sparkly without going mushy, and the Tone control stays usable across its full range.
The panel runs Level on the upper left, the three-way Mode toggle in the center, and Gain on the upper right, with Tone sitting below the toggle. Level has a lot of output on tap: in modes 1 and 2 unity gain sits around 9 o’clock, so you can push the front end of whatever comes after it without turning the Gain knob up at all.
The Mode toggle is the real personality switch. Position 1 is symmetrical LED clipping, the crunchiest and most compressed of the three, with a full, present grind that translates well through a clean amp. Position 2 removes the clipping diodes entirely and runs straight op-amp drive. The Gain knob still works, but even cranked you’re looking at light, open saturation rather than proper overdrive. It’s genuinely useful as a clean boost with a tone stack. Position 3 is asymmetrical silicon diode clipping, the closest to the original TS circuit, but with more clarity and more output level than a stock Screamer.
In the demo above I’ve set up sweeps for the “Clipping Modes” preset and the “Tone Sweep”, so you can hear all three clipping characters back to back and track how the Tone knob moves the voice from dark and round to bright and aggressive.
The presets map the range well. “Chewy not Muffled” is the pitch-perfect summary: mode 3, moderate Gain, bright Tone, that signature mid push without woolliness. “Gainy but Clear” cranks Gain to 10 in mode 1 and still holds together; LED clipping keeps it crunchy rather than fizzy. “Edge of Breakup” drops Gain to 2 in mode 3 with Level pushed up, a great amp-stack setting. “Meaty OpAmp” puts mode 2 to work with Gain at 10 and Tone rolled back. “Sparkly Dirt” shows mode 1 at medium Gain, all presence and crack.
The “Tone Sweep” preset in the demo shows how far the Tone control actually travels. It’s not just a treble filter: it reshapes the whole voice, from dark and round to bright and aggressive, which is more range than a stock Screamer gives you.
The JHS Morning Glory V4 is the other classic low/mid-gain overdrive that regularly comes up alongside the Plumes. Both are transparent-leaning with serious output headroom and both work well as always-on drives. The Morning Glory is a Marshall Bluesbreaker-inspired circuit, rounder and more open, without the focused midrange of the TS format. The Plumes has three genuinely different voices from the clipping toggle. If you already know you love the Bluesbreaker voicing, the Morning Glory is your thing. If you want flexibility and the option to dial into asymmetrical TS grit, the Plumes is the stronger cross-shop.
I’ve put it head to head on the same loop with a few of these, so you can switch between them mid-phrase: BOSS Blues Driver BD-2W vs EarthQuaker Devices Plumes, EarthQuaker Devices Plumes vs JHS Morning Glory V4 and EarthQuaker Devices Plumes vs MXR Sugar Drive.
This pedal works for anyone who wants a low-to-mid-gain overdrive that doesn’t get congested. The three clipping modes make it versatile enough for clean boost duties, classic crunch, and everything in between. It plays nicely with single-coils and humbuckers, responds well to your picking attack, and sits in a mix without fighting the amp. If you need a high-gain pedal, look elsewhere. But for blues, classic rock, indie, or anyone who just wants a great always-on drive, the Plumes is worth serious attention even if you’ve written off Tube Screamers before.
Master the dreamy, lo-fi guitar tones of Mac DeMarco, Clairo, and Rex Orange County with this complete guide to bedroom ...
A shootout of five different transparent overdrive pedals. The Bondi Effects Sick As MkIII, Plain Speak Calamity Drive, Electric Love ...
A shootout of multiple overdrive pedals. TubeScreamer, Blues Driver, Morning Glory and many more compared side-to-side. The SS/BS Mini, BOSS ...
Impulse buy here 
Fuel your tone obsession 
Indulge a little 
'Cause why not? Buy through these links and support Loopy Demos at no extra cost to you.
Get detailed specs on EarthQuaker Devices' website
<div data-loopydemos="earthquaker-devices-plumes" data-title="EarthQuaker Devices Plumes | Loopy Demos" data-width="400" data-height="610"></div>
<script src="https://loopydemos.com/embed.js" async></script>To embed this demo on your website, copy & paste the code above or customize your demo widget